
- The finished toffee
My first recipe is one I have been making for many years to great success. The original recipe is from James Beard’s American Cookery (1972, Little Brown). I have made some modifications and variations. I always make this recipe for Christmas presents and even bring it to cookie exchanges. It always impresses people to make homemade candy and this one is less difficult than the delicious taste and appearance indicate.
The key is a good candy thermometer. I recommend the Polder Candy/Jelly/Deepfry Paddle Thermometer. I got mine at the King Arthur Flour Company. This themometer has a clear read and doesn’t steam up like those hollow glass one. The glass thermometer is protected by a stainless steel metal paddle with a study clip for a heavy, straight sided pan.
Ingredients
4 cups white sugar
1 cup water
1/3 cup light corn syrup
1 pound butter- 4 sticks- cut into 12-16 pieces (I use unsalted butter at room temperature)
1 teaspoon salt
1/2 cup grated or very finely chopped untoasted almonds
1 teaspoon vanilla
chocolate chips or grated chocolate (6-12 ounces)
1/4 to 1 1/2 cups chopped toasted chopped almonds (I am very generous in almonds and use more).

Cooking Instructions
Prepare the pans. I use three cookie tins per batch. I also unwrap the butter, put it on a plate and cut it up and grease the pans lightly with the butter wrappers.
Place the sugar, water and corn syrup in a 4 quart kettle . I use a heavy All Clad pan with a lid. Clip on the thermometer. Stir gently to blend and then bring to a full boil. Wash down any sugar crystals on the side of the pan with a clean pastry brush dipped in water. (I often just avoid getting crystals on the side and skip this). Boil to 280 degree with the pan partially covered with the lid to steam the crystals down and heat faster . This takes a while but you don’t need to stir at this time. Watch the thermometer because the last 10 degrees go a lot faster. I use medium high or medium for this boil.

Stir in the butter a piece or two at a time with a wooden spoon.

The butter will make the sugar boil up to a brown froth and the temperature decreases- so room temperature butter makes this go faster. This takes a while- at least 5-7 minutes.

Add the salt and stir until the mixture reaches 315 degrees.

It can be a good idea to wear a heatproof glove. It will look silky and bubble up.

Add the 1/2 cup of untoasted ground almonds and cook until 320 or slightly below.

Take the candy off the heat and stir in the vanilla well.

Unclip and drain candy from thermometer and leave it on a plate to keep hot molten candy from burning yourself or others. This candy is lost to the ages- don’t try to sample it now. You will burn your mouth.

Immediately pour the hot toffee into the pans.

Scrape the last out but you won’t get all of it. Don’t break your heart over this, you’ve got to move quickly to spread out the toffee in the pans!

Tilt the pans and spread the toffee on the edges with the wood spoon to the thickness you like. While the candy is hot you can press in marks with a buttered knife to break it into more even pieces.

To coat the candy with chocolate on one side, sprinkle chopped chocolate chips on the still hot toffee to melt it.

Be generous. The chips will melt and turn soft and glossy.

Spread them with a spoon back to evenly coat the candy.

Then, cover the melted chocolate with chopped almonds. I like a lot of nuts.

Let it cool, even overnight. Then break into pieces. I like thinner toffee with lots of chocolate and nuts, but you can make much thicker toffee too- just use fewer pans or don’t spread it much after pouring.

Store in an airtight container. Makes a lot of toffee- depending on how much chocolate and almonds you use, up to three pounds.